I would like to incorporate the Analog Discovery into a piece of equipment, but I cannot get it to work over a longer USB cable. In fact, sometimes I can't get it to work reliably over the short USB cable that is supplied with the device. I have tried all of the tricks suggested on the forum to no avail. I have also tried a powered USB hub. It appears that it will mostly only work with the cable supplied by Digilent. This makes the device functionally useless to me. I need to be able to separate the computer and the Analog Discovery by more than 18 inches. When I try to use a cable that is 45 inches, the Analog Discovery becomes unreliable and looses communications or fails to load at all. It appears that the Analog Discovery is not fully hardware compliant with USB 2.0. To be compliant, the Analog Discovery would be able to operate over the maximum specified cable length, which is up to 16 ft. Anything less than 16 ft is noncompliant. The message that is provided is not informative enough because these solutions seem to not reliably solve the problem of Analog Discovery USB 2.0 noncompliance.
I am very disappointed with this nonconformance characteristic, because this little device is very powerful and very useful when it works. So, the problem is not that the cable needs to be shorter, it's that the Analog Discovery is not fully compliant with USB 2.0 hardware specifications.
Since the hardware is noncompliant, is there a possible software solution that could render the Analog Discovery useful over longer cables? Something like a degraded performance bandwidth due to lower communications speed, or something like that?
Question
AKH
I would like to incorporate the Analog Discovery into a piece of equipment, but I cannot get it to work over a longer USB cable. In fact, sometimes I can't get it to work reliably over the short USB cable that is supplied with the device. I have tried all of the tricks suggested on the forum to no avail. I have also tried a powered USB hub. It appears that it will mostly only work with the cable supplied by Digilent. This makes the device functionally useless to me. I need to be able to separate the computer and the Analog Discovery by more than 18 inches. When I try to use a cable that is 45 inches, the Analog Discovery becomes unreliable and looses communications or fails to load at all. It appears that the Analog Discovery is not fully hardware compliant with USB 2.0. To be compliant, the Analog Discovery would be able to operate over the maximum specified cable length, which is up to 16 ft. Anything less than 16 ft is noncompliant. The message that is provided is not informative enough because these solutions seem to not reliably solve the problem of Analog Discovery USB 2.0 noncompliance.
I am very disappointed with this nonconformance characteristic, because this little device is very powerful and very useful when it works. So, the problem is not that the cable needs to be shorter, it's that the Analog Discovery is not fully compliant with USB 2.0 hardware specifications.
Since the hardware is noncompliant, is there a possible software solution that could render the Analog Discovery useful over longer cables? Something like a degraded performance bandwidth due to lower communications speed, or something like that?
Thanks.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
2 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.